Tuesday, 28 July 2015

BANKS CAN SELL YOUR HOUSE IF YOU DEFAULT IN PAYMENTS

BANKS CAN SELL YOUR HOUSE IF YOU DEFAULT IN PAYMENTS



It is not very easy to defraud the banks and financial institutions by the defaulting borrowers since various statutory protections are provided to the lending banks and financial institutions. The activities of borrowing and lending are inseparable activities and there is a change from Savings based economy to credit based economy not only in individual's budget but also in the budget of a country.

When a person borrows money, a duty is cast on him not only to repay the money borrowed but also to pay interest in time at the agreed rate on the amount borrowed. Therefore, so long as the amount due is not repaid, there remains a liability on the borrower and this liability in other words is called the Debt of the borrower. 

Duty is cast on the lender as well to realize the money lent with interest. In spite of the fact that the lending institutions take precautions and take sufficient security for the money lent, some debts become bad and irrecoverable in the ordinary course of business. Bad debt or non-performing asset would mean an asset or account of a borrower which has been classified by a bank or financial institution as sub-standard, doubtful or loss asset in accordance with the directions or guidelines relating to asset classifications issued by the Reserve Bank of India.


Recovery of debts has become a very difficult task for the banks and financial institutions and their bad debts or non-performing assets are on the rise. The process of realization or recovery of non-performing assets (NPA) through the normal process is time consuming. To hasten or speed up the recovery process and keeping in view the alarming increase in NPAs, the Government of India has enacted the Recovery of Debts Due to Banks and Financial Institutions Act, 1993 popularly known as DRT Act. 

The DRT Act had some deficiencies inasmuch as it did not provide for assignment of debts to securitization companies and the secured assets could not be liquidated in time. Therefore, the Union Government has brought in a legislation called the Securitization and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act 2002 to remedy the deficiency. It is generally referred to as SRFAESI Act. The SRFAESI Act is not in derogation of the DRT Act. The object of the DRT Act as well as SRFAESI Act is recovery of debt through non-adjudicatory process and to provide cumulative remedies to the secured creditors.

The SRFAESI Act provides for setting up of asset reconstruction companies, special purpose vehicles, and asset management companies etc. By removing all fetters on the rights of the secured creditor, he is given a right to choose one or more of the cumulative remedies. To give more teeth to the Act,  the SRFAESI Act, 2002, has been amended in the year 2004 under The Enforcement of Security Interest and Recovery of Debts Laws (Amendment) Act, 2004, where under certain changes have been introduced in the Act by insertion of amendment or addition  to the existing sections. It is made specific in the preamble that the Act undertakes to regulate

(1) Securitization;
(2) Reconstruction of financial assets and
(3) Enforcement of security interest.
All these three concepts are independent of each other.


As far as the general public are concerned, Chapter III, Enforcement of Security Interest contained in Sections 13 to 19 are very important.   The following are the requirements for initiating action for enforcement of security interest under SRFAESI Act:

[1] The account of the borrower should have been classified as Non-performing Asset, strictly in accordance with the guidelines of the Reserve Bank of India and such other authority;
[2] Assets should not be those which have been accepted under sec.31 of the SRFAESI Act and security interest can be enforced only in respect of assets which are specifically charged;
[3] The action should be initiated well within the limitation period. If the limitation is due to expire shortly, and then it will be proper to institute a suit in a civil court or DRT as per pecuniary limit applicable for such suits.
[4] Action can be initiated only where the N.P.A.is Rs.1lakh and above.


Section 13 of the Act empowers the secured creditor to enforce the security interest in case the borrower defaults in repayment of secured debts and whose accounts categorized as non-performing asset without the intervention of the court or tribunal. The secured creditor is required to give notice under sec.13 (2) of the Act to the borrower to discharge all his liabilities in full, within 60 days from the date of notice. The notice should be comprehensive furnishing full details of the amount due and secured assets intended to be enforced. Upon receipt of the notice under sec.13 (2) of the Act, no borrower shall transfer by way of sale, lease or otherwise any of his secured assets referred in the notice without prior written consent of the secured creditor. The notice may be served by delivering, or transmitting at a place where borrower or his agent is empowered to accept the notice or documents on behalf of the borrower.

It may also be delivered or transmitted where the borrower actually or voluntarily resides or carries on business or personally works for gain. The notice may be sent by registered post acknowledgment due, by speed post, by courier, or any other means of transmission of documents like fax message or electronic mail service. If it is found that the borrower is avoiding the service of the notice, or the demand notice, or the service cannot be made, a copy of the demand notice may be affixed on the outer door or some other conspicuous part of the house or building of the borrower or his authorized agent. The demand notice may also be published in two leading newspapers having good circulation in the area, out of which one shall be in local language.

If the borrower is a corporate body, the demand notice shall be served on the registered office or any of the branches. In case of more than one borrower, the notice has to be served on each of the borrowers. The notice has to be served on guarantors and on persons who have given security for due repayment of the loan

Under Section 13(3A), if, on receipt of the notice under sub-sec.(2), the borrower makes any representation or raises objection, the secured creditor shall consider such representation or objection and if the secured creditor comes to the conclusion that such representation or objection is not acceptable or tenable, he shall communicate within one week of receipt of such representation or objection the reasons for non-acceptance of the representation or objection to the borrower, provided that the reasons so communicated or the likely action of the secured creditor at the stage of communication of reasons shall not confer any right upon the borrower to prefer an application to the Debt Recovery Tribunal under sec.17 or the Court of District Judge under sec.17A.


19. Right of borrower to receive compensation and costs in certain cases: If the Debt Recovery Tribunal or the Court of District Judge, on an application made under sec.17 or sec.17A or the Appellate Tribunal or the High Court on an appeal preferred under sec.18 or sec.18A, holds that the possession of secured assets by the secured creditor is not in accordance with the provisions of the Act and rules and directs the secured creditor to return such secured assets to the concerned borrowers, such borrower shall be entitled to the payment of such compensation and costs as may be determined by such Tribunal or Court of District Judge or Appellate Tribunal or High Court referred to in sec.18B.

If the borrower/guarantor pays the dues in full, no further action under the Act is necessary.  If dues are paid only partly and the borrower/guarantor seeks further time, the authority may decide further action with due consideration of law of limitation and the borrower or guarantor intimated accordingly. If the borrower/guarantor fails to meet their liabilities in full within 60 days from the date of the notice, the bank/financial institution can initiate action to enforce the security rights conferred on it by the Act.


The secured creditor or his authorized officer may take recourse to one or more of the measures provided in sec.13(4) of the Act to recover his secured debt who has the following options: He may take possession of the secured assets of the borrower including the rights to transfer by way of lease, assignment or sale. He may take over the management of the secured assets of the borrower, including the right of transfer of lease, assignment, and sale. He may appoint any person as the manager to manage the secured assets, the possession of which has been taken over. 

The secured creditor may require by notice any person who has acquired any secured assets from  the borrower and from whom  any money is due or may become due to the borrower to pay to the secured creditor so much of the money as is sufficient to cover  the secured debt.

Both in the case of movable and immovable properties, it is obligatory to serve a notice of thirty days to the borrower about the sale. The notice of sale shall also be published in two leading widely circulated newspapers, of which one shall be of the local language. The public notice shall contain important details of the property, the debt, reserve price, time and place of public auction, earnest money to be deposited etc. 

The notice shall be affixed on the conspicuous part of the immovable property and may also be put on Website. Sale by any other modes than public auction / tender shall be on terms settled between the parties. After confirmation and completion of sale process, the authorized officer shall issue a sale certificate in favor of the purchaser in the prescribed format.

If the secured assets are movable properties, the authorized officer shall take the possession in the presence of two witnesses and ensure that panchanama is drawn and signed by the said two witnesses. The panchanama shall conform to the prescribed format. After taking possession, the authorized officer, shall prepare an inventory of the property as per the format prescribed and shall deliver a copy of such inventory to the borrower or his authorized agent.

If the property is subject to speedy or natural decay or expenses for keeping such property is likely to exceed the value of the property the authorized officer may sell it at once. It is the duty of the authorized officer to take proper care and take steps for preservation and protection of the assets. If necessary, the assets may be insured until they are sold or disposed of.

While taking possession or sale of the secured asset, the secured creditor may request the help of Chief Metropolitan Magistrate or District Magistrate in whose jurisdictions the secured assets fall.


Under sec.17 of the Act, the person aggrieved by the actions of the secured creditor, as provided in sec.13(4) may make an application to the Debt Recovery Tribunal, having jurisdiction within 45 days from the date on which action has been taken. Similarly, any person aggrieved by the order made by DRT under section 17 may prefer an appeal to the Appellate Tribunal within 30 days from the date of the order. The party preferring appeal shall deposit 50% of the amount of debt, with a discretion given to the Appellate Tribunal to reduce the amount to not less than 25% of the debt.


The following transactions are excluded from the provisions of the SRFAESI Act:

a] A lien on any goods, money or security given by or under the Indian Contract Act, Sale of Goods Act or any other law for the time being in force;
b] Pledge of movables within the meaning of sec.172 of the Indian Contract Act,
c] Any conditional sale, hire purchase or lease or any other contract in which no security interest has been created;
d] Any property not liable to attachment;
e] Any security interest created in agricultural land;
f] Any security interest for securing repayment of any financial asset not exceeding rupees one lakh;

g] Any case in which the amount due is less than twenty per cent of the principal amount and interest thereon;

For More Information:

Monday, 27 July 2015

JOINT LIABILITIES




When two or more persons promise jointly to perform to do something for consideration it is liability of all such persons who promised to perform or to do something. Such contractual obligations of the promises are joint liabilities, which are governed by IndianContract Act 1872. We come across many such contracts in purchase, sale of the immovable properties and construction sector and also administration of partnership assets. The person who makes promise is promisor and to whom the promise made is promisee.


Section 42 of the Indian Contract Act deals with the situation. It does not makes any distinction between joint promises and several promises. According to the said section in the absence of any contrary in the contract.

1. All the persons who made promise during their joint lives are to fulfill the promise ;

2. After the death of any of the promisor, legal heirs representative of deceased promisor along with surviving promisors are to fulfil the promise; and

3. After the death of the last surviving promisor, the legal heirs, representatives of all the promisors are bound to fulfil the promise.

But if the contract provides for any contrary intention the liability devolves according to the contract.


The promisee may enforce the contract against any of promisor in case of joint promise made by two or more persons, if the terms of contract do not provide any contrary intention.However, each of the joint promisors have a right against other promisors. They may compel the other promisors to contribute equally or as provided in the contract for performance of contract.

In case of any of the joint promisors defaults in contributing towards performance the remaining joint promisors must bear the loss arising from such default in equal shares.The section 43 of Indian Contract Act makes it very clear that in case the surety makes an payment on behalf of the principal, the surety is entitled to recover the same from the principal.

The provisions of section 43 apply where two or more persons have made a joint promise. But it does not apply in case where two or more persons have become jointly interested by inheritance in a contract made by a single person. When a mortgage was executed by a single mortgagor the mortgagee suing four out of five heirs is entitled to recover only four-fifth of the mortgaged amount from them. But if the mortgage is executed by several mortgagors then the mortgagee can enforce the entire liability against a part of mortgaged property. In case of joint family debts contracted by the managing member, are the debts due for all the members of joint family and all other joint family members are bound to repay the same but their liability is not personal but only to the extent of joint family assets.


In case of a joint promise made by two or more persons, the promisee may release any of joint promisors from performing the contract. But such release does release the other promisors from performing the contract and does nor discharge the released promisor of his liability, responsibility to other joint promisors.



This is quite a different situation from what we discussed earlier. Here a single person makes a promise to two or more persons jointly. The promisor is single person and promisee are more than one. All the joint promisees during their lifetime, on death of any of them, the legal heirs / representative of the deceased promisee with other surviving promisees and on death of the last surviving promisee the representatives of all promisees jointly acquire rights to enforce the contract.

For More Information:

Saturday, 25 July 2015

FRAMING OF LEGAL SCRUTINY REPORT




The ownership of land has originated from time immemorial and has changed the hands through series of transactions. It is very important to trace the ownership of the person who is offering his property as security. One of the most important factors in verification of title is the period up to which the title has to be traced to avoid any disputes. Generally, the tracing has three important steps; origin, flow, and present status.  Most of the advocates trace the title for a period of 13 years only. Many times, not even a single transaction might have taken place within this period. This period would only remove the possibilities of adverse possession, where a person other than real owner would have been in actual, peaceful, open, continuous and exclusive possession of immovable property for a period of twelve years or more in total denial of title to the true owner, in such situations, such occupant of the property would get title to the property by adverse possession.  Apart from adverse possession, there are other situations which have to be examined to arrive at the title.

The limitation period for redemption of mortgage is 30 years as per Article 61(a) of the Limitation Act. Limitation against Government is 30 years. According to Section 90 of the Indian Evidence Act, any document executed 30 years or before is presumed to be valid, since it is beyond legal claim.

Article 61(b) of the Limitation Act prescribes limitation period of 12 years for filing suit for recovery of the possession of property who has acquired the mortgaged property from the mortgagee, without the knowledge of the mortgagor. The following example would clearly demonstrate the situation.

The limitation period for redemption of mortgage is 30 years. The mortgagee transfers the mortgaged property to another person after 29 years without the knowledge of the mortgagor. Subsequently the mortgagor comes to know of this transaction. He has right to file a suit for recovery of the mortgaged property from the purchaser and the limitation period is 12 years. The mortgage may prefer such suit within 42 years after the date of mortgage (30+12).

By examining the title and encumbrance certificates for 13 years, advocates would not be in position to trace the mortgage created earlier to 13 years, or any document executed earlier, or the claim of the Government. As such it would be preferable to trace the title for a minimum period of 42 years. This is only a minimum period and depending upon particular case tracing has to be done for more periods.

Originor First owner

The tracing should always begin with scrutiny of earliest document recorded. If such documents is not made available; the certified copies have to be obtained from registering authorities but should not be ignored.  Earlier documents are called as mother or parent documents. The partition deed, gift deed, release deed, settlement deed, power of attorney are not mother documents.

Flowof the property

Subsequently, the property generally changes hands by various modes like sale, gift, partition, inheritance. Each change of the ownership has to be traced with the help of transfer document. The sequence should be in chronological order continuous and unbroken. Any missing link has to be carefully scrutinized by referring to the records at registering offices, revenue records and recitals in other documents and if possible by ascertaining from the parties concerned. Nothing should be presumed and left to chance. The flow should be up to the ownership of present owner. The right of each intermediate owner to transfer the property should be thoroughly checked.

Presentstatus / Current owner

After examining the flow of the property, the documents of title of the present owner, through which he has acquired the ownership has to be examined. This should be further supported by revenue documents like Khatha. Encumbrance certificates, tax paid receipts, Khatha extracts.

Jointfamily properties / Hindu undivided family

The property of joint Hindu family requires extra care. Though the Khatha of the family has right to alienate such properties, it should he only for legal necessities of the joint family, if not any legal heir may dispute the transaction.

Minorproperties

Any transfer of Hindu minor properties requires permission of the Competent court, and only natural guardians / or guardians appointed by the court have to represent the minor in transactions. Minor may dispute the transactions and assert his right within three years after attaining majority, if the court has not permitted such transaction.  

Propertiesallotted/ granted by government / statutory bodies

The tracing of the title in respect of properties granted / allotted by government, statutory bodies like BDA, KHB may be done from the date of such grant/allotment.

Creationof equitable mortgage

Only the person having valid marketable title as certified by the legal advisor can create equitable mortgage in favor of the financial institutions. Legal scrutiny report should clearly specify the name of the persons who have to create mortgage.

Only original title deeds of the property should be accepted for mortgage copies of which are examined by the advocate. In case of partition, purchase of flats, certified copies of the partition, development agreement along with original documents like sale agreement, sale deed, and possession certificate may be accepted for mortgage.  Revenue documents like khatha, tax paid receipts should also be deposited.  Legal advisor should clearly indicate which are the documents that are to be accepted in original, certified copies or photocopies for deposit.



For More Information:

Friday, 24 July 2015

GUARDIANS ROLE IN MINORS PROPERTIES


Transfer of immovable property by persons domiciled in India is governed by the provisions of Transfer of Property Act, 1882. The term "Transfer of Property", as envisaged under section 5 of the Act means an act by which a living person conveys the property to one or more living persons. Living person includes a company or association or body of individuals, whether incorporated or not. However, not all living persons are competent to transfer the immovable property. Certain pre-requisites are envisaged under the statute which restricts alienation of property by a person who is not competent to enter into a contract. One such restriction is transfer of immovable property by a minor.

Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act 1956 is one such legislation which is applicable to all Hindus. It is worthwhile to deliberate who is a Hindu as per the provisions of the Act. It may be generally said that all persons other than Mohammedans, Christians and Jews are Hindus. According to the definition a person is considered as Hindu by religion in any of its forms or developments including Veerashaiva, Lingayat, followers of Brahrno Prarthana or Arya Samaj, Buddhists, Jain and Sikh.

According to Indian Majority Act, 1875, which applies to all persons domiciled in India and to all matters except marriage, divorce and adoption, every person whose property has assumed superintendence by a Court of Wards is deemed to have attained majority at the completion of 21 years and in all other cases at the completion of 18 years. Guardian means a person having care of the person of a minor or his property or both person and property.


Guardians for a minor may be classified as under:
1.   Natural Guardians
2.   Testamentary Guardians
3.   Guardians appointed by the Court
4.   De facto Guardians


Under Section 6 of the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956, the father is the natural guardian of the person and of the separate property of his minor son or a minor unmarried daughter and after him, the mother.The expression father and mother does not include step-father or step-mother.In case of adopted son, the guardian is the adoptive father and thereafter the adoptive mother. But in case of a child who has not completed five years of age mother is the natural guardian. The guardian of Hindu minor is entitled to takecare of minor's property except minor's share injoint family property. The Kartha is entitled to take care of a minor's share injoint family property. In case of an illegitimate boy or an illegitimate unmarried girl, the mother is the natural guardian and after her, the father. In the case of a minor married girl, the husband is the natural guardian. It may be generally questioned as to the provision for minor unmarried girl,as the marriage of a minor is an offence. A person is disqualified from acting as a natural guardian under this Act ifhe ceases to be a Hindu or has finally renounced the world by converting himself to a hermit.

Prior to the enactment of the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956, the natural guardian had wide powers to deal with the property of his minor son or daughter whereby he could mortgage, sell, create a charge even without permission of the Court. However, this unfettered power of the natural guardian to alienate the property of his minor children has been regulated by the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act,1956 which has been enacted keeping in view the interest and welfare of the minor children. Section5 read with Section 8(2) of the Act envisages that a Guardian cannot, without previous sanction of the court, alienate the minor's property in any manner, subject to the exception of lease not exceeding five years or not exceeding one year beyond the date when the minor attains majority. However, purchasing a property on behalf of a minor does not require court's permission. 


Testamentary Guardians mean the persons appointed through Will as guardians of minor and his property. They deal with the property belonging to the minor subject to such restrictions, as are imposed in the Will. The father may appoint any other person as guardian by a Will if the mother has expired earlier. In case the father appoints a guardian by Will even if the mother is alive it is not operative as the mother succeeds him as natural guardian. Mother may also appoint a guardian by Will, who succeeds her. In case she does not appoint any guardian by Will, the guardian appointed by the father through Will succeeds as guardian after the death of the mother. A Hindu mother may appoint any other person as guardian. The guardian so appointed shall act as natural guardian of the minor subject to the restrictions imposed in the Act and the Will. In case of minor being a girl, the powers of the appointed guardian will end on the marriage of minor girl and her husband will be the guardian thereafter. Only a person who has attained majority is competent to become a guardian. No guardian can be appointed for the undivided interest in the joint family property of the minor. However, the jurisdictional High Court may appoint a guardian for the undivided interest of the minor in joint family property.

Prior to enactment of the Hindu Minority and GuardianshipAct, 1956, a testamentary guardian appointed under the Will used to enjoy wide powers. After enactment of this Act certain sweeping changes have been introduced. It recognizes the power of a Hindu father to appoint a guardian for safeguarding the property of the minor through Will. However, no testamentary guardian can be appointed by the father for any undivided interest of the minor in a joint family property. This Act gives equal right to the mother to appoint a testamentary guardian of a minor child after the death of the father and even ifhe is alive when he has been declared as disentitled to act as the natural guardian by an order of the court or has ceased to become a Hindu due to change in religion or has renounced the world permanently.Further, the aforesaid Act also empowers the widow to appoint a testamentary guardian in respect of the person and property of her minor children.


Appointment of Guardian by the Court is governed by the provisions of the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890. Section 7 of the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890 provides that where the court is satisfied that the appointment of a Guardian is necessary to safeguard the interest of the minor child, it can make an order appointing and declaring a person as Guardian of a minor of his person or property or both. No order appointing another person to be the guardian can be made by the court until the powers of the guardian already appointed or declared have ceased to be so under the provisions of this Act.

Section 17 of the Act provides that the court, at the time of appointing or declaring the guardian of a minor, should take into consideration the age, sex and religion of the minor apart from the character and capacity of proposed guardian, wishes, if any, of a deceased parent and the existing or previous relationship of the proposed guardian with the minor child or his property. Further, court can appoint a Guardian only for the separate property of the minor and not for the undivided interest in the joint family property.

A Guardian appointed by the court has no power to alienate the minor's property without the permission of the court. Alienation without such permission is voidable at the instance of the minor and the person affected by such sale. However, if alienation has been made after obtaining necessary sanction from the court, the same cannot be challenged by the minor or any other person except in case of fraud.



A person who is not the adhoc guardian and does not act for a specific purpose as a guardian, but manages the affairs of the minor in the same manner as the natural guardian or guardian appointed by the court could be referred to as Defacto Guardian although in strict sense of the term there is nothing in the law to describe the de facto guardian. However, the authority of any person to deal with or dispose of any property of a Hindu minor on the ground of his being a de facto guardian of such a minor has been totally abrogated and any alienation by such a guardian is void abilities and the same cannot be ratified subsequently by the minor after attaining majority. Thus, it is advisable to the intending buyers of immovable property with minor's interest to take all the necessary precautions and due care before proceeding to buy the property to avoid any future complications.

For More Information: