Thursday, 23 July 2015

RIGHT OF INFORMATION ACT - BOON FOR PROPERTY MATTERS




After hectic deliberations, the Right of Information Act of 2005 finally got the nod in both the upper and lower house of the Parliament. The Act came into effect from 12th of Oct 2005. With this, the law is now valid and applicable for the whole country irrespective of any state. This Act proves as a great windfall to the property industry as the building related documents which could not be procured easily from the Government departments viz. Taluk Office, Corporation Office, Sub-Registrar Office, Survey Department, Assistant Commissioner’s Office etc., can now be got, studied and verified well in advance before embarking on any project.

This Act is a blessing in disguise for the citizens of the Nation. If used properly, this may act as a weapon to bring down the corruption level to a naught. Needless to say, corruption is rampant in our country everywhere, especially, Government departments and Municipal corporations. It is a known fact that unless the officials are bribed, nothing works. Right from the lowest level to the top level officials, the bribe gets distributed and then only the work may progress without any hindrance.  The citizen is greatly disturbed and distressed by these deeds but he can be just a mute spectator. But with the enactment of the Right to Information Act, there is a bright ray of hope as this Act gives power and paves the way for the honest citizen or a builder to get his files cleared if there is any undue delay.


At the outset, let us understand the significant aspects of this legislation.  Section 2(j) of the said Act defines the right to information.

 ‘Right of Information’ is the right to acquire information accessible under the Act which is held by or under the control of any public authority and includes the right to –
a) Inspection of work, documents, records
b) Taking notes, extracts or certified copies of documents or records
c)  Taking certified samples of material
d)  Obtaining information in the form of diskettes, floppies, tapes, video cassettes or in any other electronic mode or through printouts where such information is stored in a computer or in any other device.

A very encouraging development as far as this Act is concerned that it is just not restricted to Government and Municipal Corporations but also includes public authorities viz. organizations, NGO’s and other bodies which are financed by the Government.


Let us throw some light on how this Act can be used in practical.
1) A person submits a plan to the BMP Office for sanction. But sanctioning process undergoes an inordinate delay due to the fact of non-bribing of the concerned officials which eventually puts the citizen into a lot of anguish. Using this Act, he can now directly meet the officer and question him on the following issues.
a) What is the status of his plan?
b) How many other plans were submitted on the day on which plans was submitted by him?
c) Out of those plans, how many have been sanctioned?
d) What has happened to all the other plans?
Further, he is now entitled to ask for the inspection of documents, records, take notes and obtain certified copies.
       
2) A person applies for a ration card. As usual, it gets into rough weather
as the concerned officials are not fed properly. Now with this Act, he can go and contact the concerned and ask for the reasons for the delay just like the above case. The above said are just stray cases and the said Act can be used to elicit
any type of information from any departments except a few.


Under the Act, it is imperative now for all the administrative offices of Public Authorities to appoint a Public Information Officer. He will act as a catalyst between the citizen who wants the information and the concerned department. In normal course, the necessary information should be provided within a span of one month. There will be a nominal fee collected as a token amount. Even after one month, if the information is not provided properly or refused, the person can go one step further and appeal to the appellate authority who by default will be the senior of the said PIO in the same department.

If the Citizen wishes to appeal against the Appellate Authority itself, he should appeal to the state or Central Information Commissioner which is an independent constitutional authority.


If there is a delay in providing the information or deliberate refusal to part with the information, the PIO is penalized at Rs. 250/- per day until the information is provided to the person. This aspect may drive the PIO to act fast and provide all the information.  It is a rule that the name of the PIO should be prominently displayed at all the offices. If it is missing or the Citizen cannot find the PIO, he can apply for information by addressing to the PIO of the head office of the concerned department.

Though the Act covers almost all the departments and enables the Citizen to get the required information, Scientific, Economic, Security and strategic information as mentioned in the sections 8 and 9 of the Act may not  be disclosed or can be denied out rightly. But such a scenario may not happen as a normal citizen will not be having any business or dealings with these aspects.

The Right to Information Act is indeed a very beneficial Act for the common man and if used in a proper and optimum way, it may lead to less sleaze and more transparency.  To top it all, this act may go one step further and give a complete transparency vis-à-vis property documents which was until now not very clear on various issues.  With this Act, all the documents of property can be procured easily from the Government department’s viz. Taluk Office, Corporation Office, Sub-Registrar Office, Survey Department, Assistant Commissioner’s Office and the citizen can heave a sigh of relief.


To
The Public Information Officer,
(Name of the office with address)

1. Full name of the applicant:
2. Address
3.Particulars of the information required:
i) Subject matter of information
ii) The Period to which the information relates
iii) Description of the information required
iv) Whether the information is required by post or in person
(The actual postal charges shall be included in additional fees)
4. Whether the applicant is below the poverty line:
    (If yes, then the photocopy of the proof thereof)

Place:
Date:                                                    (Signature of the Applicant)





For More Information:

Saturday, 18 July 2015

OCCUPANCY CERTIFICATE




Occupancy Certificate is a very important document. It evidences the completion of the building as per the approved plan and compliance of local laws. Local bodies like;City Corporations/City Municipalities issue Occupancy Certificates.Without Occupancy Certificate, it is difficult to get the water and sanitary connections. Financial Institutions also insist on Occupancy Certificate.

Problems with respect to issuance of Occupancy Certificate arise on account of violation of building Law, which are increasing day by day. Though the people have spent their hard earned money on the project with a dream of owning a house, they could not occupy the house for want of Occupancy Certificate. They have to suffer for none of their faults.

Having invested their precious money in such buildings and after waiting for many years to get Occupancy Certificate, the Purchasers are forced to occupy the flats even without power, water and sewage connections instead of losing the property.

In one of the cases, a Builder was unable to obtain the Occupancy Certificate. After a prolonged wait, he requested his Purchasers and handed over the apartments without power, water and sewage connections. He put the entire blame on the Revenue Authorities and disappeared. The Occupants had to find their own ways.

Obtaining the approval of the plans has become just a formality and a casual affair. Nobody will abide by that. It is just a document to be produced during inspection. During the boom time, a Builder constructed several houses and flats violating building rules and regulations. He deviated from the approved building plans and went on to construct apartments where he should not have constructed. The Civic Authorities refused to give Occupancy Certificate despite the best efforts of the Builder.

In the mean time, the apartment Purchasers on the assumption that things were happening to their satisfaction, performed house warming ceremonies and took possession of the flats. When they were about to move in, the Builder revealed the shocking news that even though he had constructed the apartments and houses to their liking, the Authorities were not issuing Occupancy Certificate on one pretext or the other.

AnotherBuilder constructed small flats targeting the Middle Income Group (MIG). The Authorities, however, refused to issue Occupancy Certificate because of deviation from the approved plan. In this case, the Builder got the plan approved for construction of 4 dwelling units, 2 on the ground floor and 2 on the first floor. However, he did something different in gross violation of the approved plan. Instead of constructing 4 dwelling units, he constructed 6 dwelling units. The persons, who invested in Flats, are now desperate, as they would lose their money and the flats, if the Authorities decide to demolish the structure.

It is not only the flat Owners are suffering. A few Builders, who have a heart for the investing Public, too face problems. One such Builder constructed 8 flats in accordance with the building regulations and Bylaws and approved building plan. He has completed 5 flat and 3 remains to be completed. The Builder received full payment from five Purchasers while the other three backed out. This has put the Builder in a difficult situation. For want of funds, three flats remained incomplete and Occupancy Certificate could not be obtained as the Authorities will issue Occupancy Certificate only after completion of the entire construction. The Financial Institutions refused to lend in the absence of Occupancy Certificate or No Objection Certificate from the Authorities. The net result was that not only the Builder was losing money but also the Purchasers of the flats, who have to pay interest to the Financial Institutions. The Financiers too face difficulties in getting repayment of loan installments.

The Authorities in the scheme of things must be blamed for this state of affairs. The inspecting Authorities do not carry out periodic and surprise visits at the construction site. In case of deviation, they should take the Builder to task in the beginning itself and not at the flag end of the construction. Majority of the Builders follow rules and regulations but a few do not. They disobey rules and regulations and violate them.This is a vicious circle, which only the Government can break. Government must initiate immediate remedial action to stem the rot. The Authorities should not be very rigid in granting completion of Certificates. If the Builder has deviated a little more than the allowed percentage, the Authorities may impose a penalty and regularise the building.

The Investors too are responsible for this fiasco. They do not check the antecedents of the Builder and his track record. Before taking possession, they do not check whether the building is according to the agreement. Many do not demand the Occupancy Certificate, Parent Documents, Title Deeds, Deposit receipts from the Builder.The Purchaser, who has not collected the required documents, will have to face various types of problems at a later stage.


For More Information:

Friday, 17 July 2015

RENTAL AGREEMENTS

RENTAL AGREEMENTS



It would not be straightforward to unleash the property and be happy from legal proceeding unless there exists a properly written rental agreement. Therefore, it's higher to understand the salient options of the rental agreements before any property is unleash.

Rental agreements within the legal wordare referred to as Lease Agreements. The one who transfers the property is named the 'Lessor', and also the one who accepts the transfer of property is named the 'Lessee'.

According to section one hundred and five of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, a lease of unmovable property may be a transfer of the correct to relish such property, created for an exact time, specific or silent, or in sempiternity, in thought of the value paid or secure, or of cash, a share of crops, service or the other factor valuable, to be rendered sporadically or on specific occasions to the transferrer by the transferee, who accepts the transfer on such terms. In short, a lease may be a transfer of a right to relish the property of the lesssor by the tenant for sure time, throughout that amount the tenant is place in possession of the property upon payment of lease cash or rent.

The essential components of a lease are (1) parties, (2) material, (3) terms of lease (4) thought or rent and (5) length of lease. A lease dealing involves commitment by each property owner and also the tenant that are complimentary to every different - the owner agreeing to unleash his property to the tenant in thought of the latter paying him the rent and also the tenant agreeing to pay to landlord the rent in thought of the owner permitting him to use the chartered premises. A lease is that sort of encumbrance that consists of a right to possession and use of property in hand by another person. It’s the result of separation of possession and possession.

A occupancy is made not solely by an specific contract however conjointly by implication by the conduct of parties. Acceptance of rent by the owner clearly establishes existence of occupancy. A lease of unmovable property could also be established either beneath a registered instrument or beneath an unregistered instrument. However, in cases wherever the lease is from year to year or for any term extraordinary one year or reserving a yearly rent the lease is to be created solely beneath a registered instrument of lease [Sec.107 of T.P.Act] and also the lease agreements for a amount but one year don't need registration.

It is a typical apply to terminate the lease agreement at the top of each eleventh month and enter into a recent Lease Agreement since if the rent is paid on yearly basis or if the amount of lease exceeds one year, then it's necessary to register the lease agreement beneath sec.17(d) of the Indian Registration Act, 1908.

An agreement of lease ought to be written rigorously and properly to guard the rights of each the parties and to avoid any misunderstanding at a later date. It ought to be honest to each the proprietor (landlord) and also the tenant (tenant). It ought to invariably mention the parties name and address, description of the property, length of lease, monthly rent collectible, date of payment of monthly rent; clause for sweetening of rent on renewal of lease, quantity of interest-free refundable deposit, penalty clause just in case of default in payment of rent, liability of the tenant for damages to the property and also the fixtures and fittings, notice amount just in case of premature termination of lease; date of commencement of lease and also the date of expiration of lease; notice amount and manner during which the notice can got to be served etc.

The first and foremost duty of the proprietor is to abide by the terms of the lease agreement in letter and spirit and to make sure that the tenant is allowed to relish the chartered  premises while not interference. He shall got to make sure that all the essential and civic amenities square measure provided to the chartered premises. It’s the responsibility of the proprietor to hold out major repairs to the chartered  property to form it livable  and pay municipal and different taxes due on the property. The proprietor ought to make sure that the chartered  premises isn't used for any immoral or unlawful functions nor permit storing of any venturesome and ignitable materials like explosives, etc. proprietor shall issue receipts for the earnest deposit and for the rents received by him in respect of the chartered  property. The proprietor shall refund the protection deposit received from the tenant once the lease has come back to an finish. He shall not below the belt create deductions whereas refunding the protection deposit on grounds of repair to the chartered property. The proprietor is certain to divulge heart's contents to the tenant any material defect in property with respect to its supposed use of that the previous is and latter isn't aware and that the latter couldn't with care discover. The proprietor is additionally certain on the lessee's request to place him in possession of the property.

During subsistence of the lease, the tenant features a right to relish the chartered premises while not interference from the proprietor or by someone on his behalf. The tenant shall payrto the proprietor the monthly rent for the chartered premises on the in agreement date. He shall conjointly pay the electricity and water bills on or before due dates to the Legal involved authorities and furnish a duplicate of the receipt received by him from such authorities to the proprietor for his records. The tenant shall perpetually keep proprietor educated concerning the additions or alterations that the chartered  premises could need to alter the proprietor to attend to such work. The tenant shall not create any structural alterations to the premises or cause damages to fixtures and fittings throughout the subsistence of the lease. The tenant is beneath a legal obligation to not use the chartered  premises for immoral or criminal functions nor for storing the venturesome and ignitible materials like explosives, etc. The tenant is beneath obligation to use the chartered  premises for self use and to not sub-let a similar unless the lease agreement features a provision for sub-letting. He shall not cause any nuisance to the co-tenants, maintain the premises in a very livable  condition, and on completion of the lease amount, get in the chartered  premises to the proprietor while not making any nuisance upon receipt of the earnest deposit. If the proprietor fails to form any repairs, at intervals cheap time when notice, the tenant could create a similar himself and deduct the expense of such repairs with interest from the rent, or otherwise recover it from the proprietor. If the tenant involves apprehend of any recovery proceedings in respect of the chartered property, or of any encroachment, or interference with the lessor's right in respect of the chartered  premises, he's certain to offer notice thence to the proprietor.

The following grievances are usually encountered by the tenant and also the lessor:


Some lessors (landlords), for obvious reasons, fail to pay back the protection deposit to the lessees (tenants) upon termination of the lease agreement or create unreasonable deductions from the protection deposit. Generally, the landlords who in the main rely on the income and who would have used the protection deposit for his or her personal wants fail to refund the protection deposit as per agreement. Thus, once the tenant problems notice indicating his intention of vacating the chartered  premises or once the lease amount expires, some landlords would begin dodging until they get the protection deposit from another new tenant. it's the common apply that tenants opt to still occupy the chartered  premises until they come back to the protection deposit since they feel that to induce back their deposit from the owner upon vacating the chartered  premises can be a tough task.

For More Information:

Wednesday, 15 July 2015

STAMP DUTY VALUATION




The terminology 'under- valuation' is frequently used in matters of transfer of property, which has a direct bearing on payment of stamp duty and registration charges payable to Government. Before turning upon the subject 'under-valuation', it is necessary to understand the constitutional provisions relating to stamp duty. Articles 246, 265, 268, 269(1) of the Constitution of India are relevant here. Article 246 refers to the powers of Parliament and State Legislature to make laws. The Constitution of India has Union list, State list, and Concurrent list. The Parliament has powers to make laws in respect of matters mentioned in the union list and state legislatures have powers to make laws in respect of matters mentioned in the state list and both have powers to make laws in respects of matters mentioned in the concurrent list.

For day-to-day functioning and to meet administrative expenses and also for undertaking developmental works, every Government whether in the Centre or State requires revenue which is earned from different sources. Levy of tax is one such source of income to the Government. Article 265 makes it very clear that no tax shall be levied or collected except under an authority oflaw.

Stamp duty registration charges are the major sources of revenue to the State Governments. In Karnataka, the department of registration and stamp duty is ranked among the top five revenue earning departments of the State.

The stamp duty and registration charges are payable on ad valorem basis, that is based on the value of property. No maximum limit is prescribed in respect of stamp duty and registration charges payable on transfer of property. The stamp duty and registration charges go up with the increase in the value of sale consideration paid for the property i.e. higher the sale consideration, greater the stamp duty and registration charges. These charges are normally borne by the purchaser of the property unless there is a contract between the parties to the contrary effect. Apart from payment of sale consideration, stamp duty and registration charges, the purchaser has to incur expenditure to get revenue records mutated in his/her name and for transfer of power and water connections to his/her name.

To save some money from out of this expenditure, parties to a sale transaction by mutual consent mention the value of the property in the conveyance deed at a much lower figure than its actual market value and thereby pay less stamp duty and registration charges while at the same time, the purchaser makes payment of sale consideration as agreed upon to the vendor. This process of declaring the value of a property in the conveyance deed at a figure lesser than the actual sale consideration agreed upon for purposes of registration is generally known as under-valuation of the property. This modus operandi has two adverse effects on the society. Firstly, there is loss of revenue to the Government and secondly, circulation of unaccounted money in the market goes up. The Karnataka Stamp Act 1957 has certain sections dealing with under-valuation of property. Section 45-A inserted in the Karnataka Stamp Act1957, during 1975 and 45-B inserted during 1991 deal with the subject. Section 45-A deals with the procedure to be adopted where the properties are undervalued in a sale transaction.

The parties producing documents for registration have to file the market value of property calculated in the prescribed form No.l. If registering officer has reasons to believe that the market value of the property shown in the document produced for registration is not the actual value of the property in the locality, he may arrive at the market value of such property and inform the parties to pay the stamp duty and registration charges according to the market value arrived at by him. For arriving at the market value, the registering officer will use the guidelines value published by the committee constituted for estimation of market value under Sec.45-B. The values published by the committee are the guidelines value for registering offices to determine the market value. They are the average value of the property in a particular locality. If the sale consideration of a property shown in the sale deed is lower than the guidelines value pre- scribed for that area, then the stamp duty & registration charges are payable on the basis of the guide- lines value. If the market value of this property is more than the guidelines value, the stamp duty payable is as per the market value.

The registering authority informs the market value as arrived at by him in form I-A to the parties. This gives options to the parties to contest the valuation done by the registering authority, or to agree or to withdraw the document from registration.

The registering officer may proceed with the registration, if the party pays the stamp duty and registration charges as arrived at by him. If the parties do not agree with registering officer and desire to contest the same, the registering officer shall keep the process of registration pending and refer the matter to the Deputy Commissioner along with a copy of the document presented for registration for determination of the correct market value of property and stamp duty payable thereon.

The Deputy Commissioner after hearing the objections of the parties during the course of enquiry determines the correct stamp duty payable and the parties shal1 pay stamp duty and registration charges accordingly.

Many times the parties pay stamp duty as determined by the registering officer and get the documents registered. Despite this sometimes the vendor and/or the purchaser receive notice requiring them to pay stamp duty at a further enhanced figure. This is because the Deputy Commissioner has powers to initiate suo moto action without any reference to him for examination of the registered documents to ascertain whether the value of the property has been correctly shown in the (prevention of under-valuationof instruments) Rules 1977, provides guidelines to Deputy Commissioners and Divisional Commissioners to arrive at the correct market value, the procedure to be adopted to determine the market value and the procedure for conducting the enquiry, etc. The rules provide definite parameters to arrive at the market value, depending upon the nature of property such as, land, house sites, buildings, and other properties. The guidelines value are general in nature and are for guidance only.




For More Information:

Tuesday, 14 July 2015

11 MONTH LEASE DEED MUST BE REGISTERED

11 MONTH LEASE DEED MUST BE REGISTERED



HC says if unregistered, such deeds cannot be ‘received asevidence of any transaction affecting the property’

The common practice of lease deeds (including rental agreements) between property owners and tenants for 11 months to avoid registering the deed is not the right thing to do. The high court of Karnataka has held that deeds where the term of the lease stated does not exceed one year alaso have to be registered.

In a particular case, the court held that such unregistered deeds cannot be received as evidence of any dispute between the tenant and property owner, unregistered deeds will only serve collateral purpose in courts and not as evidence.

Abdul Rasheed, a tailor and tenant of Srinivas, a retired district judge, approached the HC against a lower court order that refused to accept as evidence four unregistered lease deeds. Justice HG Ramesh probed the question “Whether a lease deed, where the term of lease stated therein does not exceed one year, requires to be registered under the Registration Act, 1908”.

In a significant order that comes as a surprise to common perception of this aspect of law, the courtheld, “In law, the lease deeds of the afore to be registered and therefore, such unregistered lease deeds cannot be received as evidence of any transaction affecting the property.”

Rasheed in his petition claimed that under the Act, if the term of the lease was less than one year, there was no need for registration.

Section 107 of the Act says, “ A lease of immovable property from year to year, or for any term exceeding one year or reserving a yearly rent, can be made only by a registered instrument.” However, the HC order stressed the second paragraph of the section 107 which says, “All other leases of immovable property may be made either by a registered instrument or by oral agreement accompanied by delivery of possession.” Section 49 of the Act says that documents that need to be registered but are not cannot “be received as evidence of any transaction affecting such property.” The court held that the second paragraph of section makes it mandatory for lease deeds less than one year to be registered if they are not just oral. Therefore under section 49, they become inadmissible in court if not registered.

However, the court gave liberty to Rasheed to approach the trial court with the same documents specifically stating that they are for ‘collateral purpose’ only. Therefore unregistered lease agreements can be used only as collaborative evidence in court. The order renders most rental agreements invalid as evidence in court ifa dispute arises between the lessor and lessee.

 “Usually in disputes about rents, the rent receipts are produced as evidence. It is mostly residential properties that are registered for 11 months. Commercial properties usually have a longer lease agreement. The order is an eye-opener. In court, property owners do not produce the lease agreements as they are unregistered. If it is impounded by the court, they  will end up paying 11 times the stamp duty. This order may lead to a fresh struggle between house owners and tenants.”


For More Information: