Monday, 13 July 2015

RIGHTS & OBLIGATIONS OF SELLER & BUYER

RIGHTS &OBLIGATIONS OF SELLER & BUYER





The Transfer of Property Act, 1882, deals with various kinds of transfer of immovable property which inter-alia includes sale, mortgage, lease, exchange. In sale of an immovable property there are generally two parties to the transaction i.e. the Seller/Vendor and the Buyer/Purchaser. Section 55 of the Act refers to the rights and obligations of the seller and purchaser of an immovable property.

1.         To disclose all material defects in the property and the title to the buyer.

2.         To produce the documents of title for the verifications of the buyer on his request.

3.         To answer all relevant questions of the buyer.

4.         To execute proper conveyance deed on full payment of consideration.

5.         To take care of the property and the documents during the period between the agreement to sell and handing over possession of the property after execution and registration of Deed of Sale.

6.         To give possession of the property.

7.         To pay all taxes, charges, rents up to date and discharge any encumbrance on property prior to the conveyance of the property.

1.         To receive rents and profits of the property till its ownership absolutely passes on to the purchaser.
2.         Where the ownership has passed on to the purchaser before payment of full sale consideration, the seller will have a charge on the property for the amount of purchase money and interest on such amounts.

1.         To inform the seller any fact this may increase the value.

2.         To pay consideration amount to the seller as agreed to.

3.         Where the ownership is passed on to the purchaser, to bear the loss on account of destruction, or decrease in the value of the property not caused by the seller.

4.         To pay all taxes, charges, rents etc. where the ownership is passed on to him.

5.         The purchaser may retain the amount of any un-cleared encumbrance, out of consideration amount payable.

6.         The Purchaser is authorized to deduct the TDS (Tax Deducted at Source) at appropriate rates from the Sale consideration and remit the same into the account of Income Tax Department through the designated Banks if the sale consideration exceeds the prescribed limits.

7.        The Purchaser can pay the balance Sale consideration amount to the Seller and the same has to be reflected in the Sale Deed.

1.         Where the ownership is passed on to the purchaser the benefit of any improvement, increase in the value of the property, rents, profits.

2.         A charge on the property as against seller and all other persons claiming under him for the amounts paid by the purchaser along with interest.

The above referred rights and obligations of both the seller and purchaser are binding on both. But, section 55 of Transfer of Property Act provides an exception. If the parties to the deal have any contract contrary to the rights and obligations as envisaged in the Act, the contracted obligations and rights prevail to that extent.

The obligations and rights have relevance only where there is a valid binding contract of sale between the parties.

In case the purchaser of property declines to accept possession of the property, he has charge on the property with regard to earnest money paid and any costs awarded to him in a suit.
The rights of the purchaser are subject to certain limitations. These rights are applicable as long as the matter is in the stage of agreement and when the deal is finalized, conveyance deed is executed; the deal will come to an end. But the case is different where the conveyance is brought on account of fraud practiced by the vendor.

It is also necessary that the purchaser shall avail himself of knowledge or means of knowledge open to him or his agents to verify the credentials of the vendor, his interest, and title to the property. He has to exercise due care and diligence by exercising reasonable care and then only the purchaser can claim the protection of law for any mischief played on him.




For More Information:

Friday, 10 July 2015

JOINT VENTURE IN DEVELOPMENT AND CONSTRUCTION OF BUILDINGS

JOINT VENTURE IN DEVELOPMENT AND CONSTRUCTION OF BUILDINGS



Urbanization has accelerated migration of people to the nearby cities in search of jobs and other means of livelihood. This increased influx of population to the cities has in turn caused the paucity of residential accommodation. The employees prefer to have accommodation near to their job centers to avoid wastage of time in commuting, resulting in vertical growth of city instead of lateral growth. Vertical growth saves lot of land and can accommodate number of families in a small space. But, vertical development of land requires heavy investment; which led to joint venture.


Joint venture is joining of hands. The dictionary describes the joint ventures as “a business activity by two or more people or companies working together”. In land development also, two or more people or companies work together.

As stated above, vertical development of land comprising number of flats requires lot of money, manpower, expertise and experience which an individual cannot undertake. Many a times, the owner of the land may own lands, but may not have funds to fully exploit its potential. Similarly, the builder/ developer who have the resources may need land to employ his resources profitably. Both the owner and developer join hands to develop the land. In order to avoid disputes, misunderstandings in working, both the parties reduce the terms and conditions into writing. This is called ‘Joint Venture Agreement’.

Unlike construction of independent house, the group housing or construction of apartments is more complicated. It requires approval from various agencies like water supply board, sanitation department, power supply board, Airport Authorities and of course  approval of plans. The project requires to be approved by banks for finance. Joint venture agreements clearly earmark the duties and responsibilities for each of the parties.

In order to avoid huge amounts to be spent for the procurement of the property, the developers venture jointly with land owners through joint venture agreements, develop the property and hand over certain number of flats to the land owner. The number of flats/apartments given to the land owner depends on the prevailing market value of land in that area at the time of project commencement.


The developer or builder enters into an agreement with the owner of the land and it is known as Development agreement or Joint Development Agreement or Joint Venture Agreement. An immovable property for development may be either vacant land or land with structures thereon.
A developer or builder enters into an agreement with the owner for purchase and development of the land. The development agreement contains obligations and rights of land owners and builder, like obtaining statutory permissions, ratio of sharing the developed property between owner and developer, process of finding prospective purchasers and funding the project, time duration of completion and penalties for violation.

WHAT CONTAINS IN THE J V AGREEMENT?

The agreement contains the particulars like the liability of the promoter to construct it as per the approved plans and specifications approved by the local authority; possession date, price to be paid by the purchaser and the intervals at which the installments for the full payment are to be made specifying the stages of construction; the precise nature of the body to be constituted of the persons who would take the flats; details regarding the common areas and facilities specifying the percentage of undivided interest in the common areas and facilities appertaining to the apartment agreed to be sold; a statement of the use for which the apartment is intended; the copies of the title certificate issued and a copy of the approved plans and specification, a list of fixtures and amenities including provisions for lifts to be provided/provided for the flat to be sold should be attached to the agreement.

A promoter, while he is in possession, and where he collects from persons who have taken over flats or are to take over flats, sums for payment of out goings even thereafter, has to pay all out goings until he transfers the property. The outgoings would include ground rent, municipal and other local taxes, taxes on income, water charges, electricity charges, revenue assessment and interest on any mortgage or other encumbrances, if any.

One should also ensure that the area of the apartment has been mentioned in the agreement. It is also mandatory for the developer/promoter to convey the land in favour of the society/association of flat owners /Condominium /Company within a stipulated time.

REQUIREMENTS:

The development agreement must be in writing and the registration is not compulsory. If the developer meets the above requirements, he is well protected and starts construction work. But in case the developer commits any breach of the contract, this defense under Sec.53A cannot be availed.

Apart from the equities, the developer would have a right against a subsequent transferee of the property with notice of the developer’s right or a gratuitous transferee of the property under Sec.40 of the TP Act but not against the transferee for consideration and without notice of the rights of the developer against the property.

PROCEDURE FOR JOINT DEVELOPMENT

After examination of the property of the land owner, the developer offers him for development of the property. This offer basically consists of the percentage of the built up area which shall be offered to owner towards cost of the land and the amount of security deposit that would be paid. This security deposit is a refundable advance which has to be refunded back to the builder on successful completion of the project.

The percentage of area offered to the owner is arrived at after taking into account several factors such as cost of the land, cost of construction, escalation in cost of construction, cost of obtaining approvals for the building, marketing and administrative expenses and most importantly the selling price of apartments in that area.

If the offer is attractive, the land owner will give his acceptance and hand over a copy of the title documents to enable the builder to get the same verified by his Advocate.

If the Builder’s Advocate approves the title, a draft copy of the Joint Development agreement laying down the terms and conditions of the development is given to the landowner for his approval who generally gets it vetted by his Advocate.

If the draft of the Joint Development agreement is found to be okay, the same is prepared and prescribed stamp duty is paid. This agreement is signed by the Builder & landowner and the builder pays the first portion of the refundable advance to the landowner.

Along with the Joint Development Agreement, the landowner also gives a Power of Attorney to the Builder to apply for the various approvals required for the construction and also to sell the portion of the area coming to the Builder’s share.

All the procedures & formalities & costs for approvals are taken care of by the BUILDER.
The Builder then gets the plan prepared by an Architect, taking into account the requirements of the landowner. Once the plan is ready and approved by the landowner, the same is submitted for approval to the Government authorities.

After the plans are submitted and approved, the builder takes possession of the land from the owner. At this stage, the balance portion of the refundable advance is paid to the landowner.
After taking possession of the land, the builder proceeds to demolish the old building if any and prepares the site ready for commencement of work.

On receipt of the approval, the builder commences the construction and marketing of the project.
As and when the apartments coming to the builders share are sold, the proceeds are received by the builder in stages and the builder will register the apartments in favour of the buyers.

Out of the apartments coming to the landowner’s share, they may like to retain some apartments and sell the balance. The landowner can decide to sell his apartments initially or sell the same when the building is 50% over or when it is nearing completion or after completion. Based on the requirement, the builder will sell the landowners apartments and pass on the proceeds to the landowner as and when the same is received from the buyers. When the landowner’s flats are sold, and a certain percentage of payment is received, the landowner will have to register these apartments in favour of the buyers.

On completion of the project, the apartments retained by the landowner are handed over to them and the advance which was given by the builder at the time of commencement of the project is refunded to him.

The builder, land owner will facilitate the formation of Flat Owners Association and hand over the title documents to the Association.



As per Sec. 54 of the Transfer of Property Act, an agreement for sale does not create any interest in the property in favour of the purchaser though the consideration is paid partly or fully unless and until a deed of transfer by way of sale or lease is executed in favour of the purchaser. Many Joint Venture agreements are supported by Power of Attorney executed by owner in favour of developer for the development works and entered into agreement to sell and sale deed to the extent of developer share after completion of the total building.


For More Information:

Thursday, 9 July 2015

TRUST AND TRUST PROPERTY




Holding of property by a trustee involves various obligations and duties on the parties to a trust deed and these are enumerated in the Indian Trust Act 1882, which regulates the formation, and function of the trusts, powers and duties of trusties in dealing with trust properties.

Parties to a Trust

Trust is an obligation attached to the property thereby indicating how the property is to be used and who are the beneficiaries of the trust Property. It is an agreement between the Author of the Trust and the Trustee i.e. the manager of the trust property and the owner of the trust property. A trust may be formed by any person competent to contract, or with the permission of the court by a minor or on behalf of minor. A trust consists of more than one person that is at least two persons. The person that is the owner of the property, who reposes the confidence in another to manage the property is called author of the Trust or a settler. The person who manages the property as per the directions of the author of the trust is a trustee. 

Both the parties, i.e. the author of the Trust, and the trustee are parties to the document called a trust deed, which defines the objectives and functions of the Trust. The institution is called the Trust. Apart from the author of the Trust, and the Trustee, the third party who is entitled to the benefits is called the beneficiary, who is not a party to the Trust Deed. The beneficiary has the right to insist that the trust property can be used for their benefits although they are not a party to the said trust deed. Any person capable of holding the property can be trustee but not the government of India. Likewise a government servant cannot be a trustee of mosque, temple, church or other religious institutions.

Ingredients of a Trust:

The important ingredients of a trust are - the objectives must be certain, the beneficiaries must be certain and clear and definition of the trust property must be clear and identifiable. The trust cannot be created orally, must be in writing duly signed by the Author and it can also be created by a Will. The Trusts are of many types. A private trust, where the beneficiaries are the legal heirs of the author, or a group of individual. A public trust is one where the beneficiaries are whole lot of public. The trust may be partly public and partly private. A charitable trust is created for relief, advancement of education, religion and other purposes beneficial to the community at large.

A trust cannot be created for the following purposes 
1. Purpose, which is forbidden by law.
2. The purpose if permitted would defeat the provisions of law.
3. Fraudulent purpose.
4. Involves or implies in injury to the person, property of another.
5. The court regards the purpose as immoral or opposed to the public policy.

Creation of Trust:

A trust may be created only by a non-testamentary document that is a Trust Deed. The Trust Deed is compulsorily registerable under section 17(b) of Indian Registration Act 1908. The stamp duty payable on Trust Deed is governed by the Indian Stamp Act 1899, and falls under the powers of the States hence the stamp duty varies from State to State. It is created by a deed, it is to be registered if the value-exceeds Rs. 100. The trust act does not apply to public or private religions endowments. Section 18 of Transfer of Property Act 1882 relaxes all restrictions, in case of properties transferred for benefit of public like advancement of knowledge, religion, commerce, health and other allied objectives. A trustee cannot delegate his duties to another, except clerical duties and must have the final control over such delegation.

Bailment and Trust:

Often bailment and trust are confused. In bailment, there is delivery of goods from one person to another person for some purpose and on completion of such purpose; the goods have to be returned. In case of Trust, the property is transferred in favour of Trustee for the benefit of another person. In bailment, the person who received the goods is not the legal owner, but the trustee is a legal owner of the property.

Rights and obligations of Trustee:

The duties of the Trustee shall be well defined; he should comply with the terms of the Trust Deed, as per the directions of the author of the trust. He has to get acquainted with the property of the Trust and take required care about the genuinety and recoverability of the investments of the Trust money. The Trustee should, protect the title of the Trust property, if necessary by instituting legal proceedings. He should not set up any title adverse to the beneficiary.

He has to exercise proper care and be impartial and should prevent wastage and convert any perishable property to permanent or profitable in nature. He has to maintain proper accounts and adopt proper investment strategies. The trustees cannot commit any breach of trust, cannot set off the loss occurred because of breach of trust in one portion of the trust property against profit of another portion of trust property. When a breach of trust is committed by one trustee, all the trustees are liable to the beneficiary for the whole loss sustained. Like-wise, the trustee has certain rights, like possession of the trust deed, title deeds of the trust property, reimbursement of expenses, right to settlement of accounts, right to seek the opinion of the court. 

Maintenance of Trust Properties

The trustee may lease the Trust property for a period not exceeding 21 years without the permission of the court, may sell the property in lots, by public auction, or by a private contract. He may also sell under special conditions, and buy and resell. He has powers to make the investment of the trust property, which must be in securities listed in trust act. Any variations in investment other than listed securities must be with the written consent of the beneficiary. 

He may apply the property of the minor for maintenance of minor with proper care and discretion. After he accepts a trust he cannot renounce it except with the permission of the court, or with the consent of all the beneficiaries. Trust property cannot be used for his own benefit, and any benefit must be transferred to the trust. It is to be noted that, the trustee cannot purchase the trust property in respect of which he is trustee for sale. Even his agents cannot buy the same. Further, trustee or his agent, cannot buy the beneficiaries interest and cannot be a mortgagee, lessee of the trust property without court permission. Similarly co-trustees cannot lend among themselves. If trustee wrongfully sells the trust property, the beneficiaries have a right to follow to so long it is traced notwithstanding the intermediate ownership except in case of bonafide sale for value without the notice of the trust.

Wednesday, 8 July 2015

Deed of Covenant for Production of Title Deeds



The transfer of immovable property by way of sales, gift, will, releases etc., presupposes that documents to the title of transferred immovable property are delivered to the transferee on completion of process. This is statutory obligation. Section No. 55(3) of Transfer of Property Act, puts this responsibility on the seller. But the section has a provision, that in case where only a part of the property is sold and the seller retains a part of the property the seller is entitled to retain the original documents, and copies of such documents are delivered to the purchaser.

In case, where the property is transferred to different persons, in different lots, the transferee of greatest portion is entitled to hold the original documents of title and others are provided with copies of such documents.

In the circumstances dealt above, the persons holding the documents, either the seller or one who holds the greatest portion has some responsibilities. He has to keep the documents in safe custody and in good condition. He has to make available the documents for inspection to other buyers, and also furnish the true copies of such documents; extract from such documents, whenever required.

But the cost has to be met by the buyer who needs such inspection or copies, extracts. These responsibilities of person who holds the original property are required to be recorded properly.

The document, which records such obligations of safe keeping the documents; producing them for inspection, providing copies, extracts is called “Deed of Covenant for Production of Documents”.

The deed of transfers like sale, gift, will and release may contain such a convenant by the vendor in favour of purchaser or a separate deed may also be executed by the vendor in favour of purchaser (or) after making the same covenants can be incorporated in the sale deed.

In case of the person holding greatest portion, a separate convenant deed about his obligations becomes necessary. A separate deed in favour of each transferee of other portions or a common deed in favour of all other transferees jointly may be executed.

In the deed of transfer of the greatest portion or of higher value an explicit convenant, that, the transferee shall safe keep the documents in good condition, produce for inspection of other transferee and furnish true copies or extract should be included. Similar relevant convenant should also be incorporated in deed of transfer of other transferees.

Generally all the portions of the property are not transferred at the same time, and the above suggested procedure may not be possible. In such cases, the transferor should give a convenant of production of documents in each of the deeds of transfer and it should further provide that if and when the transferor hands over the documents to any other transferee at a later date he would procure a similar condition from the such transferee. Under a convenant of production of document, the original owner liable indefinitely unless a condition provides that he is no more responsible after he parts with the remaining portion of the property.

Flats are constructed on land and are sold to different purchasers. But the original title deeds for the entire land, will be only one and cannot be given to each and every purchaser. Each purchaser will get original sale deed, which is executed in his name and registered. He will get copies of other original documents and not originals. The original title deeds of the land will be in the custody of the Flat Owners Association. The association has the responsibility of maintaining them safely and make available the documents for inspection by the owners and to provide copies, extracts the promoters or builder shall incorporate such clause in individual sale deeds. The articles of the flat owners association shall contain the clauses relating to safe custody, inspection and making available the copies, extracts of the original documents.

Stamp Duty: in case the conditions is including in the transfer deeds itself, no separate stamp duty is payable. If a separate deed is executed, it attracts the stamp duty as that of an agreement depending upon the stamp duty prescribed by the state.

Registration: this deed of convenant does not required the registration, but it is advisable to get it registered.

Tuesday, 7 July 2015

Prohibition on Registration of immovable properties


http://advocateselvakumar.com/

Property market in Bangalore was buoyant in recent times. Rates which were upwardly mobile were settling, as mostly end users were purchasing the property. As the Real estate which is considered as mother of all industries, trades, was pulsating, many other sectors, which depend on this sector, were also prospering.

But recent government orders have stalled the growth of the property market; the sudden unexpected decisions have the effect of applying airbrake to fast moving vehicle, jolting the passengers.

Prohibition on registration:

Registering authorities have stopped the registering the sale, gift, exchange, mortgage, agreement to sell, lease or assignment or otherwise of the following properties from 06.05.2005; consequent to government notification dated 23/April/2005.

1. Site with or without building in agricultural land which is not converted for non-agricultural purpose under section 95 of Karnataka Land Revenue Act 1964.

2. Site described as Gramathana site (form no. 9, 10) or other site declared under form no. 19 under rules framed Karnataka Municipality Act 1964, but not actually converted as such site.

3. Site on a revenue land described as Gramathana Site or other site or a site with a building on which no layout plan is approved and a release certificate is issued from local planning authority like BDA, BMRDA, BIAAPA, BMIC, etc.

4. Site on a revenue land described as Gramathana site or other site, flats, industrial site, commercial site, without requisite permission under section 79 A and B read with section 109 of Karnataka Land Reforms Act.
Thus the transfer of only the following properties are permitted.

a. Properties falling under Bangalore Mahanagara Palike.
b. Properties allotted by BDA
c. Properties in BDA approved layouts
d. Properties in layouts approved by other local planning authorities like BMRDA, BIAAPA, BMIC etc.

This prohibition on registration of transfer of certain properties has given a death blow to the property market in and around Bangalore and kept it in suspended animation.

To further compound the issue, the government by its order dated 02/05/2005 has ordered not to grant permission for conversation of agricultural land in and around Bangalore until further orders. Conversion of land is prior requisite for any development, and formation of layouts. By suspending the conversion of land, the government is promoting artificial scarcity of land, it will also lead to construction of unauthorized structures.

Impact:
Many people have entered into sale agreements for purchase of properties in areas of village panchayats, City Municipalities by paying substantial amounts of advance. Most of them are of middle class. It would be difficult to get the refund of the advance paid, and the limitation period also operates against the purchaser. The properties cannot be registered. Thus hard earned money gets blocked, or may have lost for ever.

Many property developers have also invested crores of rupees in properties in forming layouts, constructing flats, villas, houses, but such layouts are not approved by planning authorities. BDA and other planning authorities are very lethargic and do not have proper infrastructure to approve the layouts in this fast developing sector. Prohibiting the registration of sites, flats in such layouts causes heavy loss to investors. Cordial relationships existed between the vendors and purchasers would disappear, and may lead to enimity, court cases.

The expected revenue from 12 registering offices in Bangalore is about 1000 crores. This is likely to go down by 50% as number of registrations come down, because of the said prohibition on registration.

Demand for sites:
The worst impact will be on price of the land, which was settling to a reasonable level in recent times. As the availability of the land is considerably reduced the property prices will shoot up to unaffordable level, as even before this prohibition the supply was short of demand. About 20,000 sites are blocked in Arkavathy Layout and their availability for public will be after protracted legal battle depending upon court verdict. The BDA has introduced the system of 10 years Lease cum Sale method, which will make the availability of the land very scarce.

Importantly, the method of operation will change. The parties will transfer the properties by executing power of attorneys, clandestine transactions will dominate the market, and no legally valid title will pass. The middle man will exploit the common man. 

No, doubt the action of the government is correct in order to ensure proper and orderly grow of Bangalore and other cities and to avoid exploitation of innocent agriculturists from land mafia. But this should have been done much earlier. It would have been better if the government has allowed registration of dealings agreed under agreements upto a particular date. 

The government should have fore-warned before issuing such far reaching notification. The value of the properties will increase in some pockets, and it will reduce in certain pockets where the registration is prohibited. People who are unaware of the government notification will invest money on such properties and finally have to loose the money.