Monday, 15 June 2015

SECURITISATION AND RECONSTRUCTION OF FINANCIAL ASSETS AND ENFORCEMENT OF SECURITY INTEREST


http://advocateselvakumar.com


Banking is centuries old, being originated in temples of Greek, where the priests were the custodians of the money of public. So is the credit. We have a classical example of Lord Venkateswara borrowing from Lord Kubera to meet his matrimonial expenses, which he is repaying continuously. A honest borrower though he taxes his devotees.

Baking and Credit are inseparable. The debt is most preferred mode of capital mobilisation. One may notice a change from Savings based economy to credit based economy. Debt is like dual edged sword, which cuts on both sides, for borrower, the repayment and for creditor the recovery.

Over the years, the recovery of loans has become most crucial and critical. The juggernaut of non-performing assets has devastating influence on many banks.

We shall understand what is Non Performing Asset (NPA). The asset is the loan given by the banks. The loan has duties to perform. It has to earn interest regularly and has to be repaid in certain time either through instalments or in bullet payment as per the agreed terms. If it fails to perform its duties, it becomes non-performing asset. The consequences is that the asset of the bank, which is public money gets locked up and finally the banks may have to write it off and naturally it is the exchequer who ultimately suffers. Reserve Bank of India has prescribed certain parameters to classify the loans as non-performing assets depending upon the duration for which the interest and instalments remain unpaid. The banks have to provide for such non-performing assets out of their profits, which erode their profits gradually.

The recovery of non-performing assets through regular courts is time consuming  and laborious process. The mounting percentages of NPA’s called for financial sector reforms. Article 247 of Constitution of India empowers the parliament to provide for establishment of additional courts for better administration of certain matters enumerated in union list. The banking, falls under union list. Recovery of Debts Due to Banks and Financial Institutions Act, 1993 popularly known as DRT was enacted to hasten the recovery process. This has many advantages. Primarily the focus on bank debts which leads to expeditious disposal to meet the urgent need. Second is the legal frame designed does not take within its fold the technical and complicated procedures avoiding delays. The DRT also protects the interest of both the creditor and borrowers. The Act faced Constitutional challenges before some High Courts, but was finally upheld by Supreme Court of India.

But the Banking Sector felt the task as incomplete as the act enables DRT to pronounce the verdict, indicting the default borrower to pay the dues or for sale of the securities. The reasons for default are many. It may be because of financial or managerial problems. It may also because of changed circumstances, policies of the government. There was need for legal framework to securitise or reconstruct the assets of the defaulting borrower as a logical end to DRT process. The lenders at times may have to step into the shoes of managers of the defaulters to efficiently manage the securities or may have to securitise them. As a result, The Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act 2002 was enacted. It is generally referred as SRAFESI.

The Act was first introduced by means of ordinance on 21.6.2002, later the Act was passed by the parliament on 17.12.2002. The ordinance as well as Act was challenged as to its constitutional validity by Madria Chemicals Limited, Siddh Industries, Indore and others. M/s. Goyal Steels and others.

The most important is Madria Chemicals Ltd. etc., V Union of India and others etc. which was decided by Honb’le Supreme Court upholding the Act except appeal cum security deposit related clause under Section 17. However the judgement has thrown open several issues which needs deeper examination. The Indian Banks Association has submitted a detailed note to the Union Finance Ministry which is likely to come out with further amendments.

As far as the public are concerned, Chapter III, Enforcement of Security Interest containing Sections 13 to 19 is very important. We shall understand some words as defined in the Act.

“Appellate Tribunal” means Debts Recovery Appellate tribunal established under Section 8 of The Recovery of Debts due to Banks and Financial Institutions Act 1993.

“Asset reconstruction” means acquisition by any securitisation company or reconstruction company of any right or interest of any bank or financial institution.

“Bank” means a banking company or corresponding new bank or State Bank of India or subsidiary bank or such other banks, which the Central Government may specify by the notification for the purpose of this Act. By special notifications, the Central Government has brought co-operative Banks, Housing Finances companies under this Act.

“Borrower” means any person who has been granted financial assistance by any bank or financial institution.

It also includes guarantor or any person who has created, any mortgage or pledge as security for financial assistance granted.

“Default” means non-payment of any interest or principal debt or any other amount payable by the borrower to any secured creditor. Consequent upon which the account of the borrower is classified as non-performing Asset as per guidelines issued by the Reserve Bank of India.

“Financial Assistance” any loan or advance granted including Debentures, bonds subscribed or any guarantees given, or letter of credit established or any other credit facility extended.

“Secured Creditor” means any bank or financial institution or any group or consortium of banks or financial institutions in whose favour security interest is created for due repayment.

“Security Interest” means right title and interest of any kind whatsoever upon property; created in favour of any secured creditor and includes mortgage, charge, hypothecation, assignment, other than those which are specifically exempted under Section 31 of the Act.

Enforcement of Security - Notice

Section 13 of the Act empowers the secured creditor to enforce the security interest in case the borrower defaults in repayment of secured debt and whose account is categorised as non-performing asset. The secured creditor is required to give notice to the borrower to discharge all his liabilities in full within 60 days from the date of notice. The notice should be comprehensive furnishing full details of the amounts due, secured assets intended to be enforced. The notice may be served by delivering, or transmitting at a place where borrower or his agent is empowered to accept the notice or documents on behalf of the borrower.

It may also be delivered or transmitted where the borrower actually or voluntarily resides or carries on business or personally works for gain. The notice may be sent by registered post acknowledgement due, by speed post, by courier, or any other means of transmission of documents like fax message or electronic mail service. If it is found that the borrower is avoiding the service of the notice, or the service cannot be made, a copy of the demand notice may be affixed on the outer door or some other conspicuous part of the house or building of the borrower or his authorised agent. The demand notice may also be published in two leading newspapers, out of which one to be in local language. The newspapers shall have good circulation in the area.

If the borrower is corporate body, the demand notice shall be served on the registered office or any of the branches. In case of more than one borrower the notice has to be served on each of the borrower. The notice have to be served on guarantors and on persons who has given security for due repayment of loan.

In case the borrower fails to repay the amounts demanded in notice, within the stipulated time, the authorised officer shall proceed with enforcement of security. The board of the bank, trust or any other authorised has to appoint an authorised officer to enforce the security, who shall not be less than rank of chief manager or equivalent. Only authorised officer shall enforce the security.

Possession

The secured creditor has some options. He may take possession of the secured assets of the borrower including the rights to transfer by way of lease, assignment or sale.

He may take over the management of the secured assets of the borrower, including the right of transfer of lease, assignment, sale. He may appoint any person as the manager to manage the secured assets, the possession of which has been taken over.

The secured creditor may require by notice any person who has acquired any secured assets by the borrower and from any money is due or may become due to the borrower to pay the secured creditor so much of money as is sufficient to pay the secured debt.

If the secured assets are movable properties, the authorised officer shall take the possession in the presence of two witnesses and after panchanama was drawn and signed by the said two witnesses. The panchanama shall conform to the prescribed format. After taking possession, the authorised officer, shall prepare an inventory of the property as per the format prescribed and shall deliver the copy of such inventory to borrower or his authorised agents.

If the property is subject to speedy or natural decay or expenses for keeping such property is likely to exceed the value of the property the authorised officer may sell it at once. It is the duty of the authorised officer to take proper care and take steps for preservation and protection of  the assets. If necessary, the assets may be insured until they are sold or disposed off. He shall get the assets valued. There are separate procedures for sale of movable and immovable properties. In case of taking possession of immovable property, a possession notice as prescribed has to be delivered to the borrower and by affixing a copy of notice on the outer door or at some conspicuous space of the property. Such possession should also be published in two leading, widely circulated newspapers. One shall be of the local language.

Sale

Both in case of movable and immovable properties, it is obligatory to serve a notice of thirty days to the borrower about the sale. The notice of sale shall also be published in two leading widely circulated newspapers, one shall be of local language. The public notice shall contain important details of the property, the debt, reserve price, time and place of public auction, earnest money to be deposited etc. The notice shall be affixed on the conspicuous part of the immovable property and may also be put on Website. Sale by any other modes than public auction / tender shall be on terms settled between the parties. After confirmation and completion of sale process, the authorised officer shall issue a sale certificate in favour of the purchaser in the prescribed format.

While taking possession or sale of the secured asset, the secured creditor may request the help of Chief Metropolitan Magistrate or District Magistrate in whose jurisdiction the secured assets, fall.

Rights to appeal

The Act provides for appeal by the aggrieved person, the borrower. Such person may appeal to the Debt Recovery Tribunal having jurisdiction. The limitation period is 45 days. Earlier Act stipulated that party preferring appeal shall deposit 75% of the amount claimed in notice with a discretion given to the DRT to waive or reduce such amount. Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of Madria Chemicals Vs. Union of India, held the provision as arbitrary and struck down this clause. There is no need to pay any deposit. The fee payable for appeal is as prescribed in Rule No. 7, Debt Recovery Tribunal procedures Rules 1993. If not satisfied with the verdict of DRT, the party may approach Appellate Tribunal within 30 days. The fees payable is as per Rule No. 8 of Debt Recovery Appellate Tribunal procedures / Rules 1999.

Limitation

Limitation Act 1963 is applicable to the Act. Taking possession, or appointing a manager or taking over the management is subject to limitations Act.

Act Not Applicable (Section 31)

The provisions of this Act is not applicable

1. A lien on goods, money, security, given by or under the Indian Contract Act 1872, or Sale of Goods Act 1930 or any other law in force for time being.
2. Pledge of movables within the meaning of Section 172 of Indian Contract Act 1872.
3. Creation of any security in any aircraft.
4. Creation of any security in any vessel (Merchant & Shipping Act 1958).
5. Any conditional sale, hire-purchase or lease or any other contract where no security interest is created.
6. Any rights of unpaid seller under Section 47 of Sale of Goods Act 1930.
7. Any properties not liable for attachment under Sub Section (1) of Section 60 of Code of Civil Procedure 1908.
8. Any security interest for securing repayment of any financial asset not exceeding one lakh rupees.
9. Any Security Interest created in Agricultural Land.
10. Any case where the amount due is less than 20% of the principal amount and interest thereon.

For More Information:



Friday, 12 June 2015

NRI HOUSING AND FINANCE IN INDIA


http://advocateselvakumar.com/

Buying a house is not difficult for NRIs any more as the NRI Housing Loan makes the property investment a lot more convenient. Any individual staying abroad for employment or for carrying on business or vocation outside India or for any other purpose in circumstances indicating an indefinite period of stay abroad are eligible for NRI Housing loan. Apart from that, government servants posted abroad on duty with the Indian missions or deputed abroad on assignments with foreign Governments or regional/ inter-national agencies are also entitled to these loans.

NRI Housing loan is offered by some of the premier financial institutions and banking in India such as ANZ Grindlays Bank, ICICI Bank, HDFC, HUDCO, CITIBANK, LIC etc. As an NRI, you can avail a maximum loan of Rs.1,00,00,000/- or 85% of the cost of the property including the cost of  land, whichever is lower. The rate of interest will vary from 11.25% to 14.25% per annum depending on the financial institution. At the time of making application for the loan a processing fee is payable which will vary between 1% to 2% of the loan amount applied for depending on the institution.

The amount of loan to be borrowed will depend upon a person's repaying capacity. To arrive at the repaying capacity banks do take into consideration factors such as income, age, qualifications, work experience, number of dependants, spouse's income, assets, liabilities, stability and continuity of occupation, alternate employment prospects when the concerned person returns to India and savings history. 

While applying for a home loans in India the following documents are to be submitted along with the application: 

-> Employment contract 
-> Latest salary slip. 
-> Latest work permit. 
-> Identity card issued by the present  employer. 
-> Visa stamp on the passport. 
-> Continuous Discharge Certificate (if applicable). 
-> Overseas Bank Account State- ment for the last few months. 
-> Receipts for payments made for purchase of the dwelling unit. 
-> Copy of approved drawings for the proposed construction/ purchase/ extension. 
-> A detailed cost estimate from Architect/Engineer for property to be purchased/ constructed / extended. 
-> Allotment letter.

Once the loan is sanctioned, the period of repayment of the loan is determined which normally falls in the range of three to ten years. Loan can be repaid through Equated Monthly Installments (EMIs) comprising principal and interest. EMI payments can  be made through post dated cheques from your Non-Resident (External) Account/Non-Resident (Ordinary) Account in India.

For More Information:


Thursday, 11 June 2015

Right to Property of Hindu Women


http://advocateselvakumar.com



Prior to Hindu Women's Right to Properties Act 1937, woman was totally excluded from taking share in the Joint Family Property. Succession to the property of male member was governed by rule of survivorship. Rule of survivorship means that on the death of a member of joint and undivided family his share in the joint family property passes on to the surviving male members called as coparceners. Mulla defines coparceners as 'The three generations next to the holder in unbroken male descent.” If a man has sons, grandsons and great-grandsons living, all of these constitute a single coparcenary with him. Coparceners jointly inherit property and have unity of possession. The co-heirs and their heirs are also called coparceners so long unity of possession continues. Co-parcenary is different from joint family. Co-parcenary is limited to three generations next to holder while the joint family has no such limitation. It includes several generations of the holder. To understand the position of Hindu women under the law of succession, it is worthwhile to know important features of co-parcenary property. There are two different laws followed by Hindus in respect of property. One is Mithakshara Law which is widely followed in India, except in West Bengal where Dayabhaga Law is followed.

Characteristics of co-parcenary property:

1. Unity of ownership: The ownership of property is vested in the whole body of the co-parceners.
2. Indeterminability of shares: The interest of a coparcener in the property is fluctuating and is capable of being enlarged by deaths in the family and liable to be decreased by births in the family.
3. Community of interest:  No co-parcener is entitled to any independent and exclusive interest in the co-parcenary property nor he is entitled to the exclusive possession of any part of the coparcenary property. His right is that of an undivided interest.
4. Rights by birth:  Co-parcenary members acquire interest in the property by birth under Mitakshara law while under Dayabhaga, nobody inherits any interest by birth.
5. Devolution of survivorship:  One of the interesting features of Mithakshara co-parcenary is that on the death of a co-parcener his interest in the property passes on to other co-parceners by survivorship (i.e. to the members who are alive). In Dayabhaga, the property devolves on the coparceners on the death of the holder. 


The Hindu Women's Right to Property Act, 1937 gave a death blow to the doctrine of survivorship.  Under this Act, the widow of a deceased co-parcener of a Mitakshara undivided family will have the same interest which her husband had while he was alive.  It may be noted that the widow has right to claim partition. With the passing of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, the position of widows and daughters came to be improved.  

Before going further into the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, it is worthwhile to examine the concept of coparcenary property. Generally speaking coparcenary property is one in which all the coparceners have community of interest and joint possession.  Such property consists of 

1. Ancestral property;

2. Property jointly acquired by the members of the joint family of HUF nucleus;

3. Separate property of a member thrown into the common hotch pot with the intention of abandoning all his separate claims on it, which becomes the property of joint family. 

4. Property acquired by all or any of the coparceners with the aid of joint family funds.

Ancestral  Property:

Ancestral property means that property which descends from father, father's father or father's father's father. The Privy Council has held that the ancestral property is confined to property inherited from the three immediate paternal ancestors and the property inherited from the maternal grandfather is the absolute property of the inheritor in which his son does not acquire any interest by birth, and that it is not ancestral.


For the purpose of succession to property by Hindu daughter the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, divides the property into four categories, thus:

1. Co-parcenary property, 
2. Property of a male Hindu, 
3. Property of a female Hindu and 
4. Dwelling house.


According to section 6 of the Hindu Succession Act 1956 when a male Hindu dies after the commencement of this Act, having at the time of his death an interest in a Mitakshara coparcenary property, his interest in the property shall devolve by survivorship upon the surviving members of the coparcenary and not in accordance with this Act.

In case there are female relatives like daughter, widow, mother, daughter of pre-deceased son daughter of predeceased daughter, widow of pre-deceased son, widow of pre-deceased son of a predeceased son, then the interest of the deceased co-parcenary will pass on to his heirs by succession and not by survivorship.

Section 6 of the Hindu Succession Act has been amended by the Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005, and according to this, in a joint Hindu family governed by the Mitakshara law, the daughter of a coparcener shall (a) by birth become a coparcener in her own right in the same manner as the son; (b) have the same rights in the co-parcenary property as she would have had if she had been a son; (c) be subjected to the same liabilities in respect of the said co-parcenary property as that of a son, and any reference to a Hindu Mitakshara co-parcener shall be deemed to include a reference to a daughter of a co-parcener.  Any property to which a female Hindu becomes entitled to under the Amendment Act, 2005, shall be a property capable of being disposed of by her by testamentary disposition i.e. by way of Will. Where a Hindu dies after the commencement of the Amendment Act, 2005, his interest in the property of the joint Hindu family governed by the Mitakshara Law shall devolve by testamentary or intestate succession and not by survivorship and the co-parcenary property shall be deemed to have been divided as if a partition had taken place. Now, there is no distinction between son and daughter in so for as the property rights in co-parcency property are concerned. However it may be noted that this benefit is not available to daughter married prior to a partition, which had been effected before the commencement of Hindu Succession (Karnataka Amendment) Act 1990. This exclusion is mainly to avoid unnecessary litigation, which may spoil cordial relations amongst the family members.

Succession to the property of a male Hindu: (Sec. 8 to 12)

The property of a male Hindu dying intestate shall devolve according to Sec.8 to 12 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956.  According to Schedule to the Act, the property will devolve firstly upon the heirs specified in class I of the Schedule; in the absence of such heirs, upon the heirs specified in class II, in the absence of heirs specified in class I and II, upon the agnates of the deceased and in the absence of agnates of the deceased, it will devolve upon the cognates of the deceased.  A person is said to be Agnate of another, if the two are related by blood or adoption wholly through males and a person is said to be Cognate of another, if the two are related by blood or adoption but not wholly through males. 

The heirs mentioned as class I heirs are son, daughter, widow, mother, son of a pre-deceased son, daughter of a pre-deceased son, son of a pre-deceased daughter, daughter of a predeceased daughter, widow of a pre-deceased son, son of a pre-deceased son of a pre-deceased son, daughter of a pre-deceased son of a pre-deceased son, widow of a pre-deceased son of a pre-deceased son. The heirs mentioned as class I shall take the property of the deceased simultaneously and to the exclusion of all other class of heirs.  

Succession to the property of female Hindu (Sec 14, 15, 16)

For the first time in the Indian history under sec. 14 of the Hindu Succession Act 1956, female Hindu is given absolute ownership over the property acquired by her by way of will, gift, purchase or in any other manner whatsoever where the terms of gift, will, or other instrument or the decree do not prescribe a restricted estate in such property.   

According to section 15 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, the property of a female Hindu dying intestate shall devolve  firstly upon the sons and daughters [including the children of any pre-deceased son or daughter] and the husband;  secondly, upon the heirs of the husband; thirdly  upon the heirs of the father; and lastly upon the heirs of the mother. However, any property inherited by a female Hindu from her parents the same shall devolve upon the heirs of her father in the absence of any son or daughter of the deceased [including the children of any pre-deceased son or daughter]. Similarly, in the absence of son or daughter of the deceased, [including the children of any pre-deceased son or daughter], the property inherited by a female Hindu from her husband or father-in-law, shall devolve upon the heirs of her husband. Among the heirs specified in sub-section (1) of Sec.15, those in one entry shall be preferred to those in any succeeding entry and those included in the same entry shall take simultaneously. [sec.16].

No person shall be disqualified to succeed to the property only on the ground of any disease, defect or deformity.

Restrictions on the rights of  Hindu female  in  the  dwelling  house:

According to sec.23 of the Act, where a Hindu intestate has left surviving him/her both male and female heirs specified in class I of the Schedule and his or her property includes a dwelling house wholly occupied by members of his/her family, the right of female heir to claim partition of the dwelling house shall not arise until the male heirs choose to divide their respective shares therein. However, the female heirs shall be entitled to a right of residence therein if she is unmarried or has been deserted by or has separated from her husband or is a widow.

Sections 25 of the Act do disqualify to inherit the property by a murderer and sec.26 of the Act disqualifies a Hindu upon conversion to any other religion.

For More Information:


Wednesday, 10 June 2015

PROPERTY GIFTED TO MINORS BY PARENTS – IRREVOCABLE


http://advocateselvakumar.com/


In an important judgement, the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, has ruled that the Property once gifted to minor children by the parents can not be revoked by them at a later stage even on the plea that the children did not expressly accepted the gift. 

While, settling an 18 year old litigation between a brother and sister over the property gifted to them by their mother, a bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India held that “where a gift is made by a parent to a child, there is presumption of acceptance of the gift by the done.” 

Looking to the details of the case, it can be found that, in 1975, one Devayani of Mayyanadcherry in the State of Kerala executed a registered Gift deed in favour of her then 16 year old son and minor daughter giving them one-half each of the landed property inherited by her from her father. However, in 2000 i.e., after 25 years, she executed a cancellation deed nullifying the Gift deed executed by her in the year 1975; and there after executed a WILL bequeathing the entire property in favour of her daughter. 

When the matter was contested, the Lower Court dismissed the suit filed by the son Sri K. Balakrishnan, claiming title to the suit property on the ground that the done was a minor at the time of execution of the gift deed and hat no one has accepted the gift on her behalf.  Even though the District Court took a view contrary to the Trial Court’s view, the Hon’ble High Court upheld the earlier verdict. 

Finally, when the matter came up before the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, set aside the Hon’ble High Court’s view and held that:  “Where a gift is made in favour of the donor, who is the guardian of the child, the acceptance of the gift can be presumed to have been made by him or on his behalf without any overt act signifying acceptance of the same by the minor.”   

Referring to the case in hand, the Bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court further held that “the knowledge of the gift deed to both the parents as natural guardians and the done (to whom property was gifted) was sufficient to indicate acceptance of the gift by the minor himself or on his behalf by the parents.  The Hon’ble Justice also held that the said gift deed was revoked by the mother much after its execution and by that time, the done had become major and that she never repudiated the gift.


Tuesday, 9 June 2015

Impracticable Stamp Duty on Joint Development Agreement


http://advocateselvakumar.com/


The words "Joint Venture" is described as "a business activity by two or more people or companies working together". Many times an individual may own some land, but may not have funds to fully exploit it. Similarly a builder/developer who has resource may need some land to employ his resource profitably. For vertical development of land which comprises of a number of flats lot of money, manpower and expertise are necessary all of which an individ- ual cannot possess. More over, unlike in the case of construction of independent house, the group housing or construction of apartments is more complicated. It requires approval from various agencies like water supply board, sanitary department, electric power supply board, Airport Authorities, Pollution Control Board, Survey Department, Telephone Department, etc. The group housing project also has to get through a much stricter compliance of procedure for obtaining project loans from the banks.

Thus, Joint Development Agreements are entered into by the land owners and the developers for mutual benefit and for the development of the property to the best advantage of both the parties. Joint Development venture is an activity of bring together the land of the land owner and the talent and expertise of the developer for creation of an asset called the apartment building. While the land owners possess certain land which is fit for development, the Developer has all the resource and talent to develop the land for construction of apartment building. He has technical skill, financial resource, capable of getting the land conversion from agriculture to nonagricultural residential purposes, capacity to get layout and plan approval from the competent authority, select the work force and drive them to achieve his goal. 

Thus, when both the land owner and the developer enter into development agreement, they would generally put forth all the relevant clauses requiring for development of the land including sharing ratio. But at that stage, the developer would not definitely calculate the financial implications involved in such ventures Based on this joint development agreement, the developer proceeds to chalk out the fine blue print of the development and takes steps for obtaining loan from the banks or financial institutions. Only upon getting the approval of the competent authority regarding land conversion, layout approval and building plan sanction the developer would take steps for ascertaining the cost of construction, or development, selection, contractors; required work force etc. The cost of units at which the developer intends to sell the individual apartment units to the prospective purchasers could be ascertained only when the final estimated figure of expenditure on men and material are ascertained by the developer which estimation at any cost cannot be done at the time of entering into joint development agreement.

Neither the land owner nor the developer would know at the time of entering into joint development agreement, the estimated court of construction or the development or the cost at which they would like to sell the apartment units to the prospective buyers and it would be premature to delve upon it at that stage.
With this background, let us analyze the Karnataka Stamp (Amendment) Act, 2009 

Under this Amendment Act, amendment to Art.S (f) has intro- duced in addition to amendments in certain sections and other Articles. Article 5 deals with agreement or [its records or] memorandum of an agreement. Article 5(t) deals with the agreements relating to construction or development or sale of an immovable property, including a multi-unit house or building or unit of apartment or flat or portion of a multi-storied building by a person having a stipulation that after construction or development, such property shall be held jointly or severally by that person and the owner or lessee of such property, or that it shall be sold jointly or severally by them or that a part of it shall be held jointly or severally by them and the remaining part thereof shall be sold jointly or severally by them. 

The stamp duty prescribed under the amended act is under:

"One rupee for everyone hundred rupees or part thereof on the market value of the property or the estimated cost of construction or proposed construction or development or proposed development of the property, which is the subject matter of such transfer under the agreement in accordance with the provisions of sec.28 of the Karnataka Stamp Act, J 957) or on the consideration for such transfer, whichever is higher. 

A reading of this amended article would go to that the stamp duty is payable in respect of joint " development agreements or in respect of sale of multi-unit house or unit of apartment or flat etc., shall be at one rupee for every one hundred rupees or part thereof of the highest of the value of any one of the following:

A] Market value of the property; 
B] Estimated Cost of construction or proposed construction on the property; 
C] Estimated cost of development or proposed development of the property; or 
D] On the consideration for such transfer of the property / flat / unit of apartment 

It would be practically difficult and almost impossible to arrive at the estimated cost of construction or development in respect of which property or the sale consideration of apartment unit which is yet be constructed of only this, the estimated cost need not be final cost. 

Suppose a developer pays stamp duty on the basis of estimated cost of construction and at a later date for obvious reasons the project comes to a halt or reduced in size, there is no provision in the Act to claim refund of the excess stamp duty paid on estimated value of cost of construction in cases where the construction is reduced in size and full refund of stamp duty paid in cases where the project is abandoned. 

The situation would be much worse in cases where the development projects are shelved after the registration of joint development agreement. 
Therefore, as a welfare state, the Government may give a fresh look to the issue of levy of stamp duty on joint development agreements to save the property developers from this unpleasant situation.

For More Information: